top of page

Cookies

Cookies

All the cookies we bake, I guess.

Holiday Box image

Holiday Box

Cookie Boy's Holiday Gift Box contains 16 Mini Cookies!

4 Frosty Boys
Dark Chocolate Peppermint Mocha Cookies made with organic dark chocolate & espresso. Topped with a wintery peppermint glaze & organic candy cane pieces.

4 Gingerbread Boys
Gingerbread Cookies elevated with fresh herbs and spices and a hand-piped, indifferent Cookie Boy frosting face.

4 Short Boys
Salted Vanilla Shortbread Cookie Bars made with brown butter, organic turbinado sugar, and an alocohol-free, pure vanilla bean paste

4 Basic Boys
Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies elevated with brown butter, organic and fair-trade semi-sweet chocolate chips, and a hint of espresso)

*Each Cookie weighs approximately 1.5oz
*Appearance of Holiday Packaging will vary

*See individual product listings for full ingredient lists*

$45

Eggs
Wheat
Frosty Boy image

Frosty Boy

Peppermint Mocha Cookie. Organic brown butter & salted dark chocolate espresso base with house-made peppermint glaze topped with crushed organic candy cane pieces.

Each cookie weighs 3oz

ingredients: cookie: unsalted butter, dark brown sugar, organic 70% dark chocolate, eggs, flour, granulated sugar, brown coconut sugar, vanilla bean paste, cocoa powder, instant coffee powder, espresso powder, peppermint extract, sea salt

icing: powdered sugar, unsalted butter, water, vanilla bean paste, peppermint extract

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Wheat
Eggs
Gingerbread Boy image

Gingerbread Boy

Gingerbread Cookie with fresh spices and grated orange zest. Featuring a Cookie Boy face piped with vanilla bean frosting.

Each cookie weighs 3oz

ingredients:
cookie: unsalted butter, dark brown sugar, molasses, eggs, flour, vanilla bean paste, baking soda, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, orange zest, allspice, sea salt, black pepper

icing: unsalted butter, powdered sugar, vanilla bean paste, oat milk

Half-Dozen

$21

Dozen

$40

Wheat
Eggs
Basic Boy image

Basic Boy

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies. Made with organic butter and organic, fair-trade semi-sweet chocolate chips, topped with flaky sea salt.

Each cookie weighs 3oz

ingredients: unsalted butter, dark brown sugar, chocolate chips, eggs, flour, granulated sugar, brown coconut sugar, vanilla bean paste, baking soda, espresso powder, sea salt

Half-Dozen

$27

Dozen

$52

Wheat
Eggs
Krispie Boy image

Krispie Boy

Brown Butter Rice Krispie Treat Cookie. Made with local Ohio butter, malted and toasted marshmallow swirls, and organic brown rice crisp cereal. Salty and sweet - a Cookie Boy fan favorite!

Half-Dozen

$27

Dozen

$53

Wheat
Eggs
Milk
Signature Cookie image

Signature Cookie

Brown Butter Oatmeal Chocolate Chip cookie topped with flaky sea salt. Made with local Ohio butter, organic rolled oats, organic & fair-trade semi-sweet chocolate chips, organic coconut, and mediterranean sea salt.

3-Pack Carton

$14.00

Half-Dozen

$26.00

Dozen

$50.00

Eggs
Wheat
Coconut
Crystal Boy image

Crystal Boy

Ube Cookies & Cream Cookie. Made with local Ohio browned butter from Hartzler Family Dairy, Ube Halaya Jam, Swiss Bourbon Vanilla White Chocolate, and Oreo pieces.

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Wheat
Eggs
Soy
Bonfire Boy image

Bonfire Boy

Dark Chocolate Smores Cookies made with Fire-Roasted Marshmallows & Honey-Baked Graham Cracker Crumble

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Wheat
Eggs
Soy
Vegan Boy image

Vegan Boy

Vegan Cornflake Marshmallow Cookie made with Mykonos Vegan Butter, Aquafaba, Organic Cornflakes, Coconut Sugar, and Dandies Vegan Marshmallows

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Vegan
Wheat
Dairy free
Tree nuts
Coconut
Lover Boy ❤️ image

Lover Boy ❤️

Dark-Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cookie. Made with local Ohio brown butter, 70% Organic Dark Chocolate, and Organic Freeze-Dried Strawberry pieces.

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Wheat
Eggs
Later Boy ✌🏼 image

Later Boy ✌🏼

Dark Chocolate Brownie Cookie with Strawberry Pieces and Raspberry Jam Filling. Made with local Ohio brown butter, Organic Strawberries, Organic 70% Dark Chocolate, and Organic Raspberry Jam.

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Wheat
Eggs
Dad Bod image

Dad Bod

Salted Caramel Pretzel Chocolate Chip Cookie topped with Potato Chips

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Wheat
Eggs
Pumpkin Boy image

Pumpkin Boy

Pumpkin Spice Latte Cookies. Made with real pumpkin, local Ohio brown butter from Hartzler Family Dairy, and filled with an espresso cream.

Half-Dozen

$30

Dozen

$58

Milk
Wheat
Eggs
bottom of page